Sturgis faces political upheaval amid leadership changes

Four years ago, the small city of Sturgis gained international attention for hosting its annual biker rally during a time when much of the country was under Covid-19 lockdown. South Dakota Governor Kristi Noem described the 10-day event as "one of the most iconic celebrations of freedom in the United States of America."

However, recent months have seen turmoil within Sturgis's local government, reflecting broader challenges faced by small towns across America. The city manager stepped down 18 months ago amid efforts to eliminate his position. This year saw further resignations from key figures including the mayor, acting mayor, city attorney, and finance director.

Council-meeting disputes spilled over into social media, resulting in a lawsuit that reached the state Supreme Court. Angela Wilkerson, who served as acting mayor from March to October, said her administration was obstructed by longtime residents and business leaders. "It's the stuff that movies are made of," she remarked.

Kevin Forrester, currently serving as acting mayor, criticized what he called a narcissistic attitude among some community members. Tammy Bohn, co-owner of Sturgis Guns and involved in lawsuits against the city, commented on the chaos: "It’s such a mess."

The Sturgis Motorcycle Rally is both a boon and a burden for the town. While it generates significant tax revenue and corporate sponsorships, it also leaves many local businesses empty for much of the year due to high real estate prices.

In 2011, Daniel Ainslie became Sturgis's second city manager with an aim to maximize rally benefits. However, his tenure ended following disputes with local traditions and institutions like the Jackpine Gypsies Motorcycle Club.

A significant conflict arose when the city attempted to annex land owned by the Gypsies. The club resisted through legal means and ultimately succeeded in reversing this decision via referendum in August 2020.

Ainslie resigned in 2023 after facing social-media campaigns against him and a lawsuit seeking to reclaim his salary. His departure came ahead of a court ruling allowing another referendum on eliminating his position.

Following these events, Wilkerson assumed office but faced financial challenges including lower-than-expected municipal sales-tax revenue. Her outsider status was criticized by some locals.

Wilkerson resigned on October 21 amid tensions and staff shortages that led to canceled city services like fall cleanup week. In her farewell letter, she cited "underhanded tactics" and a "toxic environment."

Forrester has since implemented budget cuts totaling $1.25 million to address fiscal issues while planning for future events like rally sponsorships differently.

Sturgis will hold a special election on January 7 to fill vacancies left by recent departures; however only Forrester is running for mayor at this time.